religion

Unplanned: An Honest Review

Many people pray to be kept out of unexpected problems.
Some people pray to be able to confront and overcome them Toba Beta

UNPLANNED an independent faith-based feature film, hit theaters over the weekend. Typically that’s no big deal, but this film has struck a nerve. Supporters and critics alike quickly went to their respective corners to praise or condemn it. Lost in the fray is an honest evaluation of the movie. A Crows View looks to change that oversight.

Since the hot button topic of abortion is the backdrop for UNPLANNED and Planned Parenthood the target, distinct battles lines are drawn. Unfortunately most reviews—good or bad—are based on the author’s politics rather than the film itself. That is a shame because this film deserves an honest review.

The movie centers around Abby Johnson. A young college coed from a conservative Texas family who went on to rise through the ranks of Planned Parenthood, from volunteer to clinic director. The film chronicles Abby’s life from a failed marriage and two secret abortions, to her conversion to a pro-life point of view.

Before I review the movie, there are some issues that need addressed. UNPLANNED has faced some resistance by “establishment” forces that may oppose the film because of its portrayal of Planned Parenthood and abortion. Networks and other media outlets have refused to run paid advertising for the film. Social media sites have suspended the movie’s account and even been suspected of other shenanigans involving dropping followers and restricting access. Twitter being the most prominent site accused of such behavior. The producers also blame the Motion Picture Association of America (MPPA) of playing politics for giving the film an R rating to further restrict audience reach.

These allegations are very series and they do appear to be true. According to The Daily Wire’s Paul Bois, “Lifetime, Hallmark Channel, HGTV and other cable networks…completely blocked “Unplanned” trailers from their platforms.” The Hollywood Reporter confirms this by reporting, “every other mainstream television outlet has declined to air the [UNPLANNED] ad.”

The Twitter “shadow banning” controversy appears to be working itself out. The latest numbers following a brief suspension and a click snafu with the “Follow” button shows that UNPLANNED’s Twitter handle has more than 317K followers, surpassing the film’s target Planned Parenthood by nearly 60K.

The final issue plaguing the film is it’s MPAA rating. The film makers argue it’s a targeted rating to reduce audience participation. There is a case that can be made for a PG-13 rating. The film doesn’t have nudity, sex, foul language, graphic violence or gory scenes, when compared to similar rated movies. I believe the R rating is fair giving the subject matter, content and target audience. If the MPAA did play politics with its rating, that is a shame. Since this is an issue that’s a little harder to prove malicious intent, the rating stands.

Despite the fore mentioned challenges, the film is doing quite well at the box office. Its opening weekend UNPLANNED finished in the top five overall for gross receipts.

The strength of the film can be credited to several attributes. UNPLANNED employs some great film making techniques that give it a big budget “feel.” It is also well-produced, directed and edited. The acting is another strong point in the movie, which eludes many faith-based films.

Two breakout performances standout. Both are by women. The lead actress Ashley Bratcher delivers a fabulous portrayal of Abby Johnson. Her talent and abilities were put to a test in this role, which she nailed. The range of emotions displayed throughout the film could not have been done by a lesser actress. Her performance was absolutely flawless throughout the film.

A critical scene in the film is where Abby takes part in an ultrasound assisted abortion. It is a seminole event for the character, and Bratcher delivers a particularly stunning performance. Using only her facial expression and eyes, Bratcher effectively conveys the inner turmoil at what Abby is witnessing.

The quick cuts during the abortion, from the ultrasound image to close-up shots of Bratcher’s face, made the scene more powerful. The editing and camera shots at that critical juncture in the film brought gravitas to that scene. It’s a testament not only to the genius of Bratcher, but of the crew as well.

The other breakout performance was by veteran actress Robia Scott. She played Cheryl the clinic director who took Abby under her wing and guided her career at Planned Parenthood. Scott’s performance as chief antagonist is outstanding. The role of Cheryl requires her to be disliked—if not hated—by the audience. Scott delivered; she was magnificent and realistic as the heartless corporate lackey who turns on Abby.

The confrontation scenes between Abby and Cheryl, after Abby is driven to leave Planned Parenthood, are great moments in the film. Particularly the scene when Abby is pulled to the side and admonished by Cheryl for challenging her in a meeting.

Scott’s superb performance in those scenes set up a very satisfying moment towards the end of the picture when Cheryl gets knocked down a peg or two. That satisfaction wouldn’t be possible without Scott’s impeccable execution in those earlier key scenes. The performance by Scott is a highlight of the film.

There is a lot to like about this movie. The dramatic scenes are as good as you’d see in any blockbuster. The character development is robust, and the chemistry between the cast is stellar.

Since UNPLANNED is based on the true story of Abby Johnson, who did work at Planned Parenthood in Bryan, TX and was a pro-choice advocate, may account for some corporate opposition to this feature film. Politics aside UNPLANNED is worth watching.

Actress Patricia Heaton once stated, “In reality, most women ‘choose’ abortion because they believe they have no other choice. Women who experience unplanned pregnancy also deserve unplanned joy.” That appears to be the film’s underlining message.

Ultimately UNPLANNED will only reaffirm the views of an avid pro-life supporter, while someone on the other end of the spectrum will not be phased by the “choose life” component of the film. However a person not engaged in the abortion debate, or someone contemplating having a procedure done, might be swayed by the film. That may actually be how the film makers measure success. 

Leah Shafer: Paula Abdul She Is Not!

A really great talent finds its happiness in execution – Johann Wolfgang von Goethe

Image

Like most people, I spent my Sunday watching the NFL Playoffs. After all the great plays and the wild interviews faded from my memory, I found myself thinking about the singer who performed the national anthem at the start of the AFC Championship game between the Denver Broncos and the New England Patriots.

Something about the woman singing the national anthem really stood out in my memory. The performer’s rendition of the national anthem was respectful and powerfully delivered. I was blown away by her vocal range. During the performance, I mistook her as Paula Abdul, and apparently I wasn’t the only one to make that mistake. Actor/comedian David Spade posted an Instagram post that attributed the singing to Ms. Abdul too. We were both wrong.

Image

I don’t know why, but I had a nagging feeling that I was incorrect about the singer’s identity. There was something about how she carried herself that set her apart from Paula Abdul. Her performance radiated charm and projected style. She seemed to have a certain wholesomeness that’s missing from so many celebrities. She really impressed me, and since I missed her introduction, I had to do some research to find out who this singer was.

I managed to locate a YouTube clip that gave me her name, but it took a little extra time to find out more information about her. As of this writing, the mystery singer has no Wikipedia entry, but she does have a Facebook Fan Page (only 228 followers), a Twitter feed (200 followers), and a website. She’s a devoted Christian, wife, and mother. Her name is Leah Shafer.

Shafer is a talented individual with an interesting background. Her website states, “In High School, she was chosen as ‘Best Alto’ for the California All-State Choir.” She has traveled internationally as the “main soloist of ‘The Young Americans’”; a non-profit organization and performing group based in Southern California. She’s a three-time winner of “Destination Stardom” (A PAX-TV version of Star Search) and was featured on NBC’s “The Singing Bee”.

Despite her accomplishments, she is virtually unknown to the general pubic. This is sure to change given her performance at the AFC Championship game. All things considered, I’m guessing her obscurity will not last due to her stunning recital of the national anthem. It was nice to see a decent hardworking artist get some well-deserved attention. A Crow’s View wishes her and her family the best.

http://www.leahshafermusic.com/

https://www.facebook.com/pages/Leah-Shafer/455402694551853

http://www.youngamericans.org/

http://instagram.com/davidspade

A Christmas Carol For Everyone

IMG_1562“I HAVE endeavoured in this Ghostly little book to raise the Ghost of an Idea, which shall not put my readers out of humour with themselves, with each other, with the season, or with me. May it haunt their houses pleasantly, and no one wish to lay it. Their faithful Friend and Servant”– Charles Dickens, December 1843

I have always enjoyed the Holidays. It starts with Halloween then Thanksgiving, which quickly turns into the yuletide season. Each has a distinctiveness that holds a special meaning, but Christmas is the most singular of the three.

Christmas, more than any other Holiday, is celebrated worldwide. As December 25 approaches, anticipation builds and electricity fills the air. People observe various yuletide festivities and traditions. Both rich and poor celebrate the season.

For Christians (all denominations), Christmas is the observance of the birth of their savior. It is a time to rejoice in God’s benevolence and compassion. The season is a solemn period that is marked by worshiping God through song and praise.

On the other hand, despite being steeped in religious dogma, those with a secular view of Christmas see it as an institution worthy of celebration. Its principles of peace, charity, and goodwill are noble aspects for civil society.

In both cases there is a valid reason for people to revel in the Christmas season. A particular charming part of Christmas is the many traditions people observe. For me, I always look forward to watching A Christmas Carol, the Charles Dickens’ classic tale about a crotchety old miser, Mr. Scrooge, and his reclamation.Screen Shot 2013-12-21 at 10.39.30 PM

What I like most about A Christmas Carol is its ability to bridge opposing interpretations on Christmas. For instance, people of different political or religious views will agree with Jacob Marley’s simple declaration, “the common welfare was my business; charity, mercy, forbearance, and benevolence, were all my business…” (A Christmas Carol, 52) . Marley’s statement doesn’t just set the tone for the narrative; it forges a connection with readers and viewers. In a broader sense Marley completely captures the core of the yuletide season, if not the magic of Christmas.

Marley’s statement isn’t the only time a Dickens’ character expresses an idea that is universally accepted. An earlier conversation between Scrooge and his nephew Fred has a similar effect. Scrooge’s nephew states, “I have always thought of Christmas time…as a good time: a kind, forgiving, charitable, pleasant time…when men and women seem by one consent to open their shut-up hearts freely…” (A Christmas Carol, 23). Like Marley’s declaration, Scrooge’s nephew touches upon a topic that is easily agreed upon and shared by readers and viewers.

Dickens’ genius is his ability to relate A Christmas Carol to virtually everyone. His story simply plays upon societies’ desire to see cold-hearted individuals find their humanity, while it reaffirms each individual’s view of the meaning of Christmas.

Christians associate Scrooge’s redemption as a value that is rooted in their doctrine, while the secularists see his transformation as a realigning of his ethical framework. Each group is equally pleased when Scrooge changes his ways and joins the community.

What delights people is that their view of the season is (seemingly) endorsed by the author. That is the brilliance of Dickens. He masterfully uses his characters and narrative to accomplish a remarkable feat. He gets people from all walks of life to appreciate a Christmas miracle, without getting into a religious verses secular debate. People just enjoy the story.

A Christmas Carol has withstood the test of time. It has undergone countless reproductions and remakes; yet, the core message always shines through. If you haven’t read the original book, then do so. If you prefer to watch a film, I suggest the 1984 version starring George C. Scott. In my opinion, it’s the best.

There are also some other nicely done versions that are available on the internet. The classic 1935 picture (staring Seymour Hicks) and the 1951 film (starring Alastair Sim) are fantastic black and white films. All three of these titles mentioned above are offered on YouTube.

Merry Christmas and Happy New Year.

A Christmas Carol

1935 Film

1951 Film

1984 Film

1935 YouTube Film

1951 YouTube Film

1984 YouTube Film

Pope Francis: A new era

An excuse is worse and more terrible than a lie, for an excuse is a lie guarded.Pope John Paul II

I’m not catholic, but I do find it interesting when a new person ascends to the throne of the Catholic Church. The rituals and customs of the selection are fascinating. A new Pope brings a new seal and most likely a new direction. It will be interesting to see where Pope Francis will take the 1.2 billion believers.

The election of Pope Francis provided lots of fodder for the TV viewing audience. It’s hard to believe that in a secular world this process dominated the media the way it did. I can only conclude that the Catholic Church is still relevant and going strong after 2000 years and 266 different pontiffs. The Pope and the seal may change, but the church’s message remains the same. It’s no wonder that the catholic church has endured as long as it has.

One word of caution. The Catholic hierarchy needs to address the recent scandals in a manner far different than the papal conclave. The process needs to be transparent and quick. Hopefully the new Pope, who cherishes the poor and disenfranchised the way Cardinal  Bergoglio did, will translate into action. If the new Pope deracinates the corrupt priests and cardinals who protected the perpetrators of children, then his accession to the popacy will truly be worthy of worldwide adoration.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_Francis